The Difference Between Loyalty and Competence
Every leader wants trustworthy people around them.
There is nothing inherently wrong with trust.
But loyalty cannot replace competence.
Imagine choosing a surgeon because that person supported your political campaign.
Imagine selecting an airline pilot because that person is your cousin.
Imagine hiring an engineer to build a bridge because that person is your friend.
Most people would immediately recognize the danger.
Yet governments sometimes entrust equally important responsibilities to people without demanding adequate competence.
A minister may oversee billions in public resources.
An administrator may manage an entire government agency.
An engineer may oversee critical infrastructure.
A health official may influence decisions affecting millions of people.
Qualifications matter because consequences matter.
When Merit Disappears, Excellence Leaves With It
Now return to Nadia.
She did everything society told her to do.
Study.
Work hard.
Develop skills.
Gain experience.
Prepare yourself.
But she discovers that none of those things matter as much as knowing the right person.
What lesson does she learn?
Perhaps:
“Why should I continue trying?”
Or:
“Maybe there is no future for me here.”
Eventually, Nadia receives an opportunity abroad.
She leaves Haiti.
Another country gains:
Her education.
Her skills.
Her productivity.
Her taxes.
Her creativity.
Her leadership potential.
Haiti loses them.
Multiply Nadia by thousands of doctors, nurses, engineers, teachers, entrepreneurs, technicians, administrators, academics, and young professionals.
Now we begin to understand something important:
Nepotism can contribute to brain drain.
When people believe opportunity depends more on connections than ability, talented citizens have powerful incentives to search for environments where merit is more likely to be rewarded.
The Poor Pay the Highest Price
It is tempting to think nepotism affects only people seeking government employment.
That is incorrect.
Imagine that an unqualified individual is appointed to oversee a municipal water system.
Who suffers?
The citizens.
Imagine an incompetent administrator manages a hospital.
Who suffers?
Patients.
Imagine someone without appropriate expertise manages an infrastructure project.
Who suffers?
Taxpayers and everyone who depends on that infrastructure.
Imagine public funds are managed by people who lack the necessary financial expertise.
Who suffers?
The entire country.
Competence in government is not an employment issue alone.
It is a public-service issue.
Haiti: When “Who You Know” Becomes More Important Than “What You Know”
Many Haitians are familiar with the perception that connections can influence access to opportunities.
This challenge is not unique to Haiti. Nepotism, patronage, and cronyism exist in countries throughout the world.
But where institutions are weak, their consequences can become especially damaging.
A developing nation cannot afford to waste talent.
Haiti needs its best:
Teachers.
Doctors.
Engineers.
Economists.
Agricultural experts.
Accountants.
Technology professionals.
Urban planners.
Public administrators.
Lawyers.
Entrepreneurs.
Scientists.
Security professionals.
And ethical public servants.
Every important government position filled primarily through favoritism represents a potential opportunity lost to build stronger institutions.
